[Duratrix]

This thread was made to rate each others sig(s) and avatar.
Give a rating from 1 to 10, on which 1 is really bad and 10 is great.

Important!!
Give a decent explanation why you gave the person above you a certain rating.
We do not want spam here!!

Example:
Do not say something like: "sig 1/10 - cuz it sucks" or "sig 1/10 - because it's Naruto", but instead say something like this: "sig 1/10 - the colors aren't good with the render, the render is also to bad quality, ...".

[bass]

8/10 I find your singnature very nice but I think he would have been even better if the lighter or darker background would have been


but that is my opinion

[Kelisidina]

^ 5/10. The whole thing is kinda dull, will you be able to save it with higher quality? If not, I'm sorry. The pics on the left are way too dull, try some icon coloring on them. The bg for the guy feels a bit empty; try adding more brushes. I also think he would have been better with a white stroke rather than a black one. But I like the text, and it was a nice idea. You just have to learn how to execute it better. ^^ Extraction is really good too.

[Expertee]

Ava 7/10 looks like just a picture to me

sig 7/10.
its very simple and clean, but has the common mistake of no blending between BG and renders/stock. Also never separate text, specially placing them in completely different corners from each other, its very distracting and a big no no. try adding some adjustment layers on an applied image for some blending.

[GodsDragon]

ava */10 cannot be rated because has none

sig 7/10 Its pretty unique but I find that it is lacking a wow factor that will make me remember it. The face shots do add a bit of style and the red filter is a nice touch. But for my taste it could use more boobs.

[mehrunmastadons]

avatar:9\10-------i like this-nyaaaw!!!i had this gif and some body hold her tail and she became horny!!!!
because of that neko i like nekos!!!
sig:8\10--------so funny and awesome quality with nice subject!!!
and spoil: 10\10 kawaaaaaiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii!!!!!

[Iduno]

Avatar 7/10 nicely done but doesn't realy catch the eye.
Sig 0/10 sig is absent.

[ZEE]

Originally Posted by mehrunmastadons

avatar:9\10-------i like this-nyaaaw!!!i had this gif and some body hold her tail and she became horny!!!!
because of that neko i like nekos!!!
sig:8\10--------so funny and awesome quality with nice subject!!!
and spoil: 10\10 kawaaaaaiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii!!!!!

just fyi eruru is a inu-shoujo just thought you should know

I thought there was a thread for this already.
But... it was on the void xD

[Kelisidina]

^ Icon: Nice and smooth, just needs a border 9/10
Sig: The effects didnt mesh well together, the colours dont match the girl. Text is awkward, and the girl is LQ. Still, not bad. 7/10

@Expertee: Umm... You do know I recolored her eyes and added border+bg, right?