|

12-11-2010, 04:12 PM
It's hard not to offer criticism without analysing the text, but in any case...
It's probably best to place the positive comments at the start and say I really like this monologue. It is simultaneously emotionally evocative and natural-feeling. The slightly unstructured, rambling feeling of it could sink a lot of pieces, but here succeeds in building a sense of background and character without deviating too far from the main narrative thread.
On to the specifics.
"Though instead of being Tuxedo Mask, he drives you to near insanity because he likes to lean on your shoulder which sends electric shocks flowing through you and you just want him to lean a little closer so like magnets north and south connect creating the euphoric field known as a kiss." This will be a lovely hypnotic run-on sentence (assuming you're OK at reading out loud), but the ending needs adjusting as it doesn't fit together grammatically in a fairly obvious way. Possibly you mean "so, like magnets north and south, YOU connect..." Incidentally, I don't see a regular 18-year old using the word "euphoric" - perhaps you have a more erudite class of 18-year old where you come from.
Also, "Though instead of being Tuxedo Mask" seems a little puzzling. What are you contrasting? If it's Tuxedo Mask's mystery and remoteness versus feeling your beloved's presence up close, I'm not sure the contrast comes through very clearly. Maybe "Though, unlike Tuxedo Mask" would serve better.
"however, I was upset by the young and upstart New Orleans Saints." I think you belabour the metaphor too far here. You (or the character; forgive me if I am mistaken in using the two interchangeably) were never in competition with anyone in this story, so speaking as if you were makes the reader stop and try to work out whom the New Orleans Saints are meant to represent for you.
"the same way Twilight fans recall Jacob’s chiseled abs." Memorable, unique metaphor for the win. That should get plenty of laughs from the audience.
"Tuxedo Mask leaning by the window pretending to act all nonchalant." The metonymy of calling him Tuxedo Mask directly here is very elegant. On the other hand, how do you know his behaviour is pretense? Throughout the piece, he is portrayed as acting in a relaxed and comfortable way, which suggests that he is not obsessing over hidden feelings the way the narrator is. Thus, this description seems rather strange. Also, "pretending to act" seems like a tautology.
"I seem to identify a lot with the main character, Taiga." A few words to sketch out Taiga's character here would do wonders in deepening the parallel you later draw between you and her. Also, I have never been able to identify with a tsundere character even slightly, so I'm grateful to your monologue for giving me a little insight.
"This ritual was followed by the tradition of “arguing” as he calls it. I just like to provoke him because it’s fun." A person after my own heart, I see. That aside, you make "arguing" sound like something special (thanks to "as he calls it"), without explaining what makes it so. Perhaps you could elaborate on what makes this activity different from "just arguing", or rephrase to indicate that what you do *is* normal arguing, but the way you do it is what makes it a tradition?
Got to run. I'll post the rest of my comments later today when I get back.
|