[Titens]

Utawarerumono's my favorite visual novel by far. The characters are incredible, the story is one of the best too, and it has a funny strategy rol game inside. The anime is good, but it could have been better.

Fate Stay Night is my second favorite, and the only one that is close to utaware. Once again, great characters and storyline, and in this case, it was well adapted into the anime.

I guess my 3rd favorite would be tsukihime... but this visual novel doesn't have an anime.

I really want to play clannad's and shuffle's visual novels, but they haven't been translated yet. And I might give chaos head a chance once it's fully translated.

As for the doujin games, i've played a bunch of them, but apart from melty blood all the rest were crap.